Maddux, Glavine, and Smoltz


And Aaron, Mathews, and Spahn. And Jason Heyward. And Andrelton Simmons. Did I mention Jason Heyward?

Why did I buy these cards?

In the picture above, you can see the new baseball cards that I’ve purchased since the start of the 2015 collecting season. These boxes contain complete sets of the following:

  • 2015 Topps Series 1
  • 2015 Topps Series 2
  • 2015 Topps Heritage Master Set
  • 2015 Topps Allen & Ginter Set
  • 2015 Topps Update Series

These boxes were all purchased from a case breaker who has always been more than fair to me. If I want new baseball cards in the year they are released, this seems to me the best way to do it. I can let the breaker have fun with the added value and I can pay for only the cards I know I want. I don’t have to open a pack of cards and wonder if the card I’m looking at is a variation or the card that belongs to the main set. I don’t have to worry about parallels. I can only purchase the insert sets I actually want to keep.

This arrangement has worked for me for a few years now, but there’s a catch. Through 2014, within a week of receiving my sets, I would have them in binders. I would carefully go through each set and examine each card, even reading the backs on Heritage and most base Topps cards. Even if there were numerous things I didn’t like about the sets, I still managed to enjoy them.

I thought that the 2015 Topps set was easily the most interesting base set they’ve put out in a long, long time, and yet, mine sits in the box it was shipped in. I thumbed through Series 1 when I received it, but Series 2, Update, Heritage and A&G are unmolested. This raises the question: why did I buy these cards?

It’s not a question I can answer yet other than to say, I’m not ready to give up on new baseball cards just yet. I don’t want to be sitting here in a few years wondering why I stopped.

One note: not all of my 2015 baseball card sets were purchased already completed from a case breaker. I put together 2015 Topps Stadium Club together through retail purchases, one random lot on eBay and a few trades. This is easily my favorite Topps set since the early Allen & Ginter sets. I’ve never seen better photography in a baseball card set. (It’s far superior to the tightly cropped action photos that dominate the base set.) This set was the most few I’ve had with new baseball cards in year and I figure there’s no way Topps can screw it up in 2016 either. I’ll be back! (Wait - variations and short prints? Crap.)

My First Completed Page of 1954 Topps

The arrival of 2016 Topps Series 1 has convinced me that I should focus on building a few vintage sets since I have no intention of building a modern set. (I buy them already completed occasionally, but I can't imagine buying an unopened box.) The question becomes: which vintage sets should I make a go at? I settled almost immediately on 1954 Topps as one of those sets. I had toyed with the idea last year and purchased a few cheap lots off of eBay, but I then went through a period of what I can only call "collecting ennui". I had to contemplate whether I still wanted to be a part of this hobby or not. I went almost three months without buying a single card, which I haven't done since I returned to collecting 11 years ago. But, I've got the bug again. Maybe it's the new season being upon us, but I want baseball cards.

So, here's my thinking on trying to complete a 1954 Topps set: I already have the Hank Aaron rookie and there's no Mickey Mantle card. I love Mickey Mantle as a historical baseball figure, but I have no interest in paying the premium his cards command if I can avoid it. As for the Aaron rookie, it's the one baseball card I've always wanted, and owning it is nothing short of a dream come true. (I pull it out of a binder every few days and just sort of stare at it in awe.)

So, the Aaron makes an impressive start to the set, but if you know vintage sets, you know the cards that will make this set difficult, or rather expensive, to complete. There’s the Ernie Banks rookie. There’s the Al Kaline rookie. Jackie Robinson and Willie Mays are in the set. More importantly, there are the two Ted Williams cards that bookend the set. I can only hope that somewhere out there, there are two perfectly creased Ted Williams cards with my name on them. That, however, is a story for another day.

I work from home and occasionally, I work for a client who thinks its a good use of time to keep consultants on the phone for the most pointless meetings. Yesterday, I literally spent three continuous hours on the phone and did not have to say a single word. There was not one word said about any of my projects. If I’m at the office, all I can do is stare at the other people in the room with contempt. Since I work from home, I got out a 2 inch binder, a box of 8 count pages, and my stack of 1954 Topps baseball cards. By the end of the meeting, my future set was in the binder, my want list was posted on the web site, and a scan of my only full page wasn’t completed. Now that’s what I call productive.

There are so many great players in this set even beyond the Aaron, Kaline, and Banks rookies. Not one of those great players appears on my first completed page and that’s OK. This is still an interesting group of guys.

  • I’m not overly familiar with Roy Smalley’s career, but I know his son was an All-Star for the Twins.
  • Don Liddle pitched for the Braves and was traded for Giants playoff hero Bobby Thompson. He was also the man on the mound when Willie Mays made the catch.
  • Bob Talbot had what was basically a cup of coffee with the Cubs and was then traded to “the Sox”, but would never play another inning in the big leagues.
  • Buster Mills appeared in 341 games in his career for the Cardinals, the Dodgers, the Red Sox, the Browns, the Yankees and the Indians. The year before this set was put out, he managed the Reds.
  • Gene Hermanski greeted Jackie Robinson with a handshake in the Dodgers dugout in 1947 and was the player who suggested that the entire team wear the number 42 to confuse any potential snipers.
  • Like Mills, Bob Kuzawa got around. He threw 862 innings in the big leagues for 8 different teams.And yet, there are still people who believe that everyone played their entire careers for a single team before free agency.
  • My favorite Lou Limmer story is that he lied to the A’s about his age to try and get a larger signing bonus.
  • My favorite player on the page is the late Jay Heard from Athens, Georgia. After a few sporadic appearances in the negro leagues, he moved on to the independent minor leagues where after a few seasons of success, his contract was purchased by the Orioles. Heard was shelled in the second of his two appearances and was sent down to the minors. He never got another taste of the big leagues. This, unfortunately, was not at all uncommon for black players at the time. You were either great, or you were in the minors.

This Card Sucks

I think I sometimes give off the impression that I don’t like modern baseball cards. That isn’t really true. Taken in isolation, I think there are a great many modern baseball cards that are quite beautiful and will stand the test of time. (I will admit that I don’t care for most modern baseball card sets with last year’s Stadium Club set standing as a wonderful exception.)

I’m one of those old collector’s who has a litany of complaints about how today’s sets are constructed, but it boils down to one thing: I hate gimmicks. The very notion of a gimmick is that baseball cards are not, in and of themselves, good enough. They are not a worthwhile investment of our time or money. That’s an idea I reject. I get far more excited about a [base card] than I could ever get over an insert, a parallel, the increasingly ridiculous hits and other card company ideas of “added value”, the most preposterous phrase ever used in conjunction with baseball cards. ([Chris Harris addressed this in an epic rant a few years ago.])

There is one gimmick that I like however. I love the idea of Topps buying old baseball cards and sticking them as inserts into modern sets. I love the idea that someone who has never had any interest in vintage cards could find a card that stokes that interest. I love that collectors of modern cards can get a little history lesson of the hobby in a pack of new cards. It’s one of those gimmicks that should be magnificently easy to pull off. And Topps screws it up anyway.

I’ve yet to purchase a pack of 2016 Series 1, but I did participate in a group break where I got all the Braves out of a case. One of those cards is the 1975 Lew Krausse you see above. This is a card that I would have loved to have pulled out of a pack. Although I already have two copies, one in my 1975 set binder and another in one of my Braves team set binders, I almost certainly would have replaced one of those with this. This card is in nearly pristine condition. Yet, I hate this card and I would never sully one of my vintage binders with it.

That blue foil stamp. That awful blue foil stamp. Why? What’s the stinking point of that blue foil stamp? I’m not asking rhetorically. I want to know the point of that damned foil stamp. Do you know what’s arguably the best quality of a vintage Topps baseball card? NO F’N FOIL. A vintage baseball card does not need improving. Vintage baseball cards are just fine, thank you very much. Does Topps really think that someone needs reminding that they pulled this card on their 65th anniversary? Does Topps think that defacing a beautiful vintage baseball card with a foil stamp adds value to the card? Seriously, what the HELL.

It’s an assault on taste. It’s an assault on vintage baseball cards. It’s an assault on long time baseball card collectors. This card makes me sick.

Hello ...

It's me. Chris. I used to blog occasionally (rarely?) at another blog with the same name. I also used to write about collecting at Talking Chop but that seems like a million years ago.

I'm going to try and make a go of it again. If you were subscribed to that old feed, it's as dead as Upper Deck's line of baseball cards. You can find the new feed link somewhere on this page. I think.

As for comments, I'm still working out the kinks with Disqus, but if they aren't available yet, they will be shortly. As a rule, I like people who comment on baseball card blogs. Mostly. Certainly better than people who comment on YouTube videos.

What can you expect?

  • An old man bitching about Topps and any other manufacturer who makes "modern" baseball cards.
  • Nothing about Topps Bunt or any other virtual card product.
  • Unrelenting, never-ending, gut-wrenching hatred spewed in the direction of the Cardinals, the Nationals, the Cardinals, the Mets, the Cardinals and the Red Sox. And the Cardinals. Especially the Cardinals.
  • Slobbering over 50 year old pieces of cardboard with deep creases and a torn off corner or two.
  • Stuff about the Braves and how much they suck.
  • Other stuff.

I'm giving it the undersell. Really. It's going to be, uh, great or something. You'll see. Or you won't. That's OK too. Life goes on.

I'm ending this post with my favorite baseball card in my collection. It's my 1954 Topps Hank Aaron, complete with soft corners and ROLLER MARKS~!

My 1954 Topps Hank Aaron rookie card, complete with ROLLER MARKS!